What If the Sun Disappeared?

The Sun cannot switch off. That is the first thing to say, and everything else here follows from ignoring it. But ask the impossible question anyway — what if the Sun vanished this instant? — and physics gives an answer that is precise, and surprisingly slow to arrive.

Nothing happens for eight minutes and twenty seconds.

The eight-minute delay

Light from the Sun takes about 8 minutes and 20 seconds to cross the 150 million kilometres between us. If the Sun disappeared right now, the sky would stay blue, the light would stay warm, and Earth would sail on through space as if nothing had changed. We would be orbiting a star that no longer existed, and we would not know it. Mars rovers would wait about 12 minutes, and a probe out by Pluto would not notice for over four hours.

The orbit lets go — also after eight minutes

Here is the twist that makes the thought experiment worth running. Gravity does not travel instantly. General relativity predicts that changes in a gravitational field propagate at the speed of light, and astronomers have confirmed the speed indirectly by watching the orbital decay of the binary pulsar PSR B1913+16. So for those same eight minutes and twenty seconds, Earth would keep orbiting a Sun that is already gone.

Then the signal stops. The planet does not spiral away or explode; it simply leaves its orbit along a straight line, tangent to the path it was following, at its current speed of about 30 kilometres a second — roughly 108,000 kilometres an hour.

Darkness without a sunset

There would be no long dusk and no fading orange sky. The light would simply stop, the way a lamp stops when the switch is flipped. The sky would be dark except for the stars, and the Moon and the other planets would vanish almost immediately, because they shine only by reflecting sunlight.

How fast the cold arrives

Without solar heating, the average surface temperature would fall by roughly 20 degrees Celsius a day at first. Within a week the global average would be below freezing. Within a year it would be around minus 73 degrees Celsius — minus 100 Fahrenheit — colder than anywhere naturally recorded on Earth, comparable to a Martian winter. Rain and weather would stop entirely, because the water cycle is driven by the Sun.

The oceans freeze from the top

Ocean surfaces would begin icing over within weeks. That ice would be a blanket rather than a tomb: it would insulate the water beneath it, so the deep ocean could stay liquid for hundreds of thousands of years. Eventually the whole planet would settle near minus 240 degrees Celsius (minus 400 Fahrenheit), the point at which heat leaking from Earth's core equals the heat the planet radiates into space — an estimate from David Stevenson, a planetary scientist at Caltech. Carbon dioxide would also begin freezing out of the atmosphere at about minus 78 degrees Celsius, falling as dry ice.

Life's last shift

Photosynthesis would stop immediately. Most plants would die within days to weeks; large trees might survive a few decades on slow metabolism and stored sugars. Herbivores would starve first, then predators, then the scavengers picking over what was left. The oxygen in the air would last about a thousand years, so suffocation would not be the first crisis — cold and hunger would get there long before.

Some life would outlast the surface. Microbes living in the crust and around deep-sea hydrothermal vents feed on chemical energy rather than sunlight, and they would keep going. Humans could hold on in geothermal- or nuclear-powered habitats; Iceland already heats about 87 percent of its homes geothermally.

The Sun's real deadline

The Sun is not a lamp we can switch off. Its mass and energy are conserved, so it cannot simply vanish. The real story is slower and, in its way, stranger: the Sun is getting brighter. In about a billion years its output will be roughly 10 percent higher than today, which is enough to create a moist greenhouse and boil away Earth's oceans. In roughly five billion years it will exhaust its hydrogen and swell into a red giant, possibly engulfing the planet. The vanishing is fiction. The deadline is not.

What you'll find in this episode

• Why nothing happens for the first eight minutes and twenty seconds
• The twist: gravity travels at the speed of light, so the orbit survives the Sun
• How Earth would leave the solar system in a straight line at 30 kilometres a second
• The freeze timeline — a week, a year, a hundred thousand years
• Why the oceans freeze from the top down, and why the deep sea stays liquid
• How the food chain collapses long before the oxygen runs out
• The real future of the Sun, and the one-billion-year deadline it is already counting toward

Key moments

• 00:00 Eight minutes of normal
• 00:15 What if the Sun vanished?
• 00:26 The Sun's two jobs
• 00:39 Orbiting a ghost
• 00:59 The long freeze
• 01:34 The Sun is not permanent

None of this will happen. The Sun will not blink out; it is a star with billions of years of fuel and a habit of getting brighter. The thought experiment is useful precisely because it is impossible. It measures how much of our world — the weather, the food, the oxygen, the shape of every ordinary day — is a loan from one star. We cannot lose the Sun tomorrow. We can notice what we would lose.

Watch the full video on YouTube

▶ Watch the full video on YouTube

Exploring the strange questions about humans, science, history and the world around us. @TheQuestionArchive